Switch 2 Pro Controller vs Xbox Wireless Controller: Which Should You Buy?
A Switch 2 pad with a built-in battery against Microsoft's AA-powered controller for Xbox and PC.
Nintendo Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller
Xbox Xbox Wireless Controller – Carbon Black Series X|S
Side by side
| Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller | Xbox Wireless Controller – Carbon Black | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | See on Amazon → | See on Amazon → |
| Rating | ★★★★★ 4.8 | ★★★★★ 4.6 |
| Review count | 3,150 | 3,352 |
| Brand | Nintendo | Xbox |
| Highlights |
|
|
Our verdict
Match the controller to the console. The Switch 2 Pro Controller is made exclusively for Switch 2 and adds motion sensors, NFC, mappable back buttons and a GameChat button. The Xbox Wireless Controller works with Xbox consoles, Windows, iOS and Android, and runs on AA batteries. If you play on Switch 2, buy the Pro Controller. If you play on Xbox or PC, buy the Xbox one. Don't assume the Xbox pad works on Switch 2, because Xbox's page doesn't list it.
Which one is for you?
- Suits Switch 2 owners wanting motion controls, amiibo and GameChat in a full-size pad. Read our full look at the Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller →
- Suits Xbox and PC players, or phone gamers using Bluetooth, who want a familiar pad that takes AA batteries. Read our full look at the Xbox Wireless Controller – Carbon Black →
Platform support
Nintendo's Switch 2 accessories page lists the Switch 2 Pro Controller as made exclusively for Switch 2, and the listing says it's only for use with that console.
The Xbox Wireless Controller is listed by Xbox for Xbox consoles, Windows PC and iOS and Android devices, over Xbox Wireless or Bluetooth. A Nintendo console isn't listed there, so we haven't treated it as compatible.
Battery and charging
The Pro Controller has an internal 1070 mAh battery that isn't user-removable. Nintendo estimates about 40 hours, with roughly 3.5 hours to charge via USB-C. Microsoft says the Xbox controller lasts up to 40 hours on AA batteries by its own testing, and the listing says USB-C gives plug-and-play on console or PC. So the figures match on paper, but AA means you can swap cells and keep playing.
Buttons and features
Nintendo lists GL and GR buttons, a C button, Capture, motion sensors, HD Rumble 2, NFC and a 3.5 mm audio jack, about 235 g in weight. The listing also notes amiibo support.
Xbox's pad has textured triggers, bumpers and a hybrid D-pad, a Share button, a 3.5 mm headset jack and button mapping through the Xbox Accessories app, which on Windows needs a USB-C cable. Xbox's page doesn't list motion controls.
Who should skip both
If you play on PlayStation, see DualSense vs Xbox Wireless Controller. For cloud gaming pads see Luna Controller vs Xbox controller. Switch 2 owners wanting smaller options can read Joy-Con vs Switch 2 Pro Controller, or browse Switch 2 accessories.
Questions people ask
Can I use an Xbox controller on Switch 2?
Xbox's page lists Xbox consoles, Windows, iOS and Android, not Nintendo consoles. Check Nintendo's compatibility page before relying on it.
Is the Switch 2 Pro Controller worth it?
If you want a full-size pad on Switch 2, yes: mappable GL/GR, motion sensors, NFC and about 40 hours of quoted battery life.
Does the Xbox controller use batteries?
Yes. It supports AA batteries, with up to 40 hours quoted by Microsoft, and the listing mentions USB-C for plug-and-play.
Does the Pro Controller have a headphone jack?
Yes, a 4-pole 3.5 mm CTIA port, though Nintendo can't guarantee every product works with it.
Does the Switch 2 Pro Controller need a subscription?
The controller doesn't, but online services need a Nintendo Account and paid Nintendo Switch Online membership.
Sources
- Nintendo, Switch 2 Pro Controller
- Xbox, Xbox Wireless Controller
Prices are pulled live from Amazon.
Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Nintendo Switch 2 or see the whole Video Games department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.