Amazon Luna vs Xbox Wireless Controller: Which Should You Buy?
A controller made for one cloud service against a general-purpose Xbox pad.
Xbox Xbox Wireless Controller – Carbon Black Series X|S
Side by side
| Amazon Luna Wireless Controller | Xbox Wireless Controller – Carbon Black | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | See on Amazon → | See on Amazon → |
| Rating | ★★★★☆ 4.4 | ★★★★★ 4.6 |
| Review count | 4,838 | 3,352 |
| Brand | Amazon | Xbox |
| Highlights |
|
|
Our verdict
Buy the Luna Controller only if Luna is your main way to play, since its selling point is Cloud Direct, a Wi-Fi connection straight to Luna's servers. For almost everyone else, the Xbox Wireless Controller is the more flexible pad: it works on Xbox consoles, Windows, Android and iOS, and takes AA batteries. Check that Luna is available in your region before buying a controller for it.
Which one is for you?
- Cloud gamers who play on Luna and want lower-latency, device-switching play across Fire TV, PC, phones and tablets. Read our full look at the Amazon Luna Wireless Controller →
- Anyone who wants one controller for Xbox, PC and phones, whatever service or store they play on. Read our full look at the Xbox Wireless Controller – Carbon Black →
Connection options
The Luna Controller connects three ways: Wi-Fi through Cloud Direct, Bluetooth, and wired USB-C. iFixit lists Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, a wired USB-C connection and an audio jack, and the listing says Cloud Direct links the pad straight to Luna's servers for low-latency play. The listing also says you can pause on one screen and pick up on another.
The Xbox Wireless Controller uses Xbox Wireless on consoles and Bluetooth on Windows 10/11, tablets, iOS and Android, per Microsoft. It also has a USB-C port for direct plug and play.
Power
iFixit lists two AA batteries for the Luna Controller and quotes up to five hours of battery life. Microsoft quotes up to 40 hours from AA batteries for the Xbox controller, with life varying by accessories. Those are separate manufacturers' figures, so treat them as indicative.
The Luna Controller weighs 235.5 g without batteries and 281.5 g with them, according to iFixit.
What they work with
The Luna listing names Windows, Mac, Fire TV, Fire tablet, iPhone, iPad, Chromebook, Android and select Samsung and LG smart TVs. Cloud Direct is the part tied to Luna itself; Bluetooth lets it act as a general controller on compatible devices.
The Xbox pad is the Xbox-native choice, with a hybrid D-pad, Share button and button mapping in the Xbox Accessories app.
Who should skip both
If you play on PlayStation, see the DualSense against the Xbox Wireless Controller. Switch 2 players should look at the Switch 2 Pro Controller against the Xbox controller.
Questions people ask
Is the Luna Controller better than the Xbox controller?
Only for Luna cloud gaming, where Cloud Direct reduces latency. For general use the Xbox controller is more flexible.
Does the Luna Controller work with Xbox consoles?
The listing doesn't name Xbox consoles. It lists Windows, Mac, Fire TV, Android, iOS and Chromebook, so check before buying it for an Xbox.
What batteries does the Luna Controller use?
Two AA batteries, with iFixit quoting up to five hours of life.
Does the Xbox controller work on iPhone and Android?
Yes, Microsoft lists Bluetooth support for iOS and Android.
Do I need a subscription to use a Luna Controller?
The controller's Cloud Direct feature is for playing on Luna. This page doesn't cover Luna's subscription terms, so check the service itself.
Sources
Prices are pulled live from Amazon.
Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Xbox Series X or see the whole Video Games department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.
