ChoiceTally is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Make-up · Head to head

NYX Brow Pencil vs e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil: Which Should You Buy?

Two dual-ended brow pencils with a spoolie: NYX leans waterproof and shade-rich, e.l.f. leans simple.

NYX Professional Makeup Brow Pencil, Micro Brow Dual Ended Ultrafine Pencil Tip with Mechanical Brow Tool and Spoolie Brush, NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Brow Pencil, Micro Brow Dual Ended Ultrafine

★ 4.4 / 5 41,968 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →
e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil, Dual-Sided, Precise, Fine Tip, Shapes, Defines, Fills Brows, Contours, Combs, Tames, Natural e.l.f.

e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil, Dual-Sided, Precise, Fine

★ 4.3 / 5 71,128 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →

Side by side

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Brow Pencil, Micro Brow Duale.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil, Dual-Sided
PriceSee on Amazon →See on Amazon →
Rating★★★★☆ 4.4★★★★☆ 4.3
Review count41,96871,128
BrandNYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUPe.l.f.
Highlights
  • Dual-ended eyebrow pencil with an Ultra thin retractable brow pencil and spoolie brush, For drawing, shaping a…
  • Delicate, super natural-looking result, Ideal for sparse or over-tweezed brows Lightly colour in brows with pe…
  • Use built-in spoolie brush to distribute colour and shape brows Long-lasting and natural finish formula with a…
  • SHAPE, DEFINE, FILL Our instant lift eyebrow pencil shapes, defines, and fills in brows for a natural, polishe…
  • LONG LASTING STYLE Achieve precise lines and perfectly contoured brows that last for hours with this amazing e…
  • HOW TO USE Utilize the spool brush to comb eyebrows into desired shape, then use the liner to fill in brows wi…

Our verdict

Choose the NYX Micro Brow Pencil if you want a twist-up mechanical tip and a waterproof, smudge-resistant formula in a wider shade range. Choose the e.l.f. Instant Lift if you want a simple pencil and spoolie in a smaller set of shades, with a budge-resistant claim rather than a waterproof one. For sparse brows drawn in hair-like strokes, the finer mechanical tip is the safer bet.

Which one is for you?

Tip and formula

One retailer page describes the NYX Micro Brow Pencil as dual-ended with a skinny twist-up mechanical nib, so you never sharpen it, and a spoolie for blending. It calls the tip micro precise and break resistant. The product is listed as waterproof, smudge resistant and all-day wear.

e.l.f.'s page for the Instant Lift Brow Pencil describes a dual-ended pencil with a fine precision tip and a spoolie, with budge-resistant colour. It does not describe it as waterproof, so if you need that, don't assume it.

Shades

The retail page for NYX lists eight shades in its selector: Ash Brown, Auburn, Black, Blonde, Brunette, Chocolate, Espresso and Taupe. The listing text talks about 12 waterproof shades, but the page we checked shows eight, so confirm your shade is stocked.

e.l.f.'s UK page lists Taupe, Neutral Brown, Deep Brown, Blonde and Auburn, and its shade guide also covers Black. It advises picking a shade one to two tones darker than your hair if it's light, or one to two lighter if it's dark.

How to use

NYX's instruction is to use short upward strokes in the direction of hair growth, fill gaps, extend where needed and blend with the brush, ideally in good light. e.l.f. suggests combing brows upward with the spoolie, filling sparse areas with light hair-like strokes, blending and then adding a brow gel for hold.

Neither brand claims a permanent result. For long wear, a brow gel over either pencil is the standard approach.

Ethics labels and who should skip both

NYX's page states the formula is vegan and cruelty free with no animal-derived ingredients. e.l.f.'s page labels its pencil 100% vegan, cruelty-free and Fair Trade. If you want a filled-in, defined block brow or microblading-style effect, a brow pomade or tint will do more than either pencil.

Questions people ask

Is the e.l.f. brow pencil waterproof?

e.l.f.'s page for the Instant Lift Brow Pencil describes budge-resistant colour and doesn't call it waterproof.

Is the NYX Micro Brow Pencil waterproof?

The retail page lists the NYX Micro Brow Pencil as waterproof, smudge resistant and all-day wear.

Which has more shades, NYX or e.l.f.?

NYX's retail page lists eight shades, e.l.f.'s UK page lists five plus a Black in the shade guide. Check stock for your colour.

Do they come with a spoolie?

Yes, both are dual-ended with a spoolie brush on one end.

Are NYX and e.l.f. brow pencils vegan?

Both brands label their pencils vegan and cruelty-free on the pages we checked.

Sources

Prices are pulled live from Amazon.

Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Make-up or see the whole Beauty department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.