ChoiceTally is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Make-up · Head to head

Maybelline Lash Sensational vs L'Oreal Telescopic Mascara: Which Should You Buy?

A volumising mascara with a layered brush against a lengthening mascara with a separating comb.

Maybelline Mascara, Lash Sensational Volumizing & Thickening, Eyelash Lengthening, Flake Free Formula, Layer Reveal Brush, De Maybelline

Maybelline Mascara, Lash Sensational Volumizing & Thickening, Eyelash

★ 4.4 / 5 74,303 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →
L'Oréal Paris Mascara, Telescopic Original Mascara to Achieve Dramatic Length & Definition, Up to +71% Lengthening Effect, Sm L'Oreal Paris

L'Oreal Paris L'Oréal Paris Mascara, Telescopic Original Mascara to

★ 4.3 / 5 83,661 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →

Side by side

Maybelline Mascara, Lash Sensational Volumizing &L'Oreal Paris L'Oréal Paris Mascara, Telescopic Original
PriceSee on Amazon →See on Amazon →
Rating★★★★☆ 4.4★★★★☆ 4.3
Review count74,30383,661
BrandMaybellineL'Oreal Paris
Highlights
  • From a well-known manufacturer.
  • Highly rated by Amazon shoppers (4.4/5).
  • See the latest price and availability on Amazon.
  • Precision mascara, for lash by lash maximum intensity, Supple elastomer bristle comb for gentle application, S…
  • Up to 60% longer looking eyelashes, Precise application lash-by-lash, Layer for more intense colour and volume
  • Comb through lashes from root to tip, repeat as desired for more volume and intense colour

Our verdict

Pick L'Oréal Telescopic if you want length and clean separation, since that is exactly what its comb brush and 'longer-looking lashes' claim are built around. Pick Maybelline Lash Sensational if you'd rather have volume and thickness. Check which Lash Sensational version you are buying, because Maybelline sells several with different brushes.

Which one is for you?

What each one is built to do

The Maybelline Lash Sensational listing describes a volumizing and thickening mascara with a flake-free formula and a Layer Reveal brush. Maybelline's own UK site shows the Lash Sensational name covers several versions, including a washable one with a fanning brush of ten bristle layers and a Sky High version with a bendable brush, so the original and the others are not interchangeable.

The L'Oréal Paris Telescopic Original is the lengthening one. L'Oréal's UK page says it separates lashes with a comb brush so they don't clump, and gives a figure of up to 70% longer-looking lashes from an instrumental test on 27 subjects (a banner on the same page says 71%). The retail listing words the claim as up to 60%, so treat the exact percentage loosely.

Wear, comfort and removal

L'Oréal quotes up to 36 hours of wear from a consumer test of 108 subjects and calls the formula flake-resistant and smudge-resistant. It says the mascara is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. These are brand test claims, not independent results.

Maybelline's UK page for the washable Lash Sensational version says it is ophthalmologist tested, suitable for contact lens wearers, and removes with micellar water or a gentle eye makeup remover. We couldn't verify equivalent statements for the original Layer Reveal version, so check the pack before assuming the same.

How to apply them

L'Oréal's instruction is to comb through from root to tip, moving the brush back and forth, then add more coats for volume. A separating comb rewards patience: build slowly and it keeps lashes distinct.

A layered-bristle brush like the Layer Reveal is aimed at picking up small lashes and adding body in fewer passes, according to the listing's description of the design.

Who should skip both

If you want waterproof wear for swimming or heavy rain, look for the clearly labelled waterproof versions in each range rather than these base formulas. If you want a dramatic curl, consider a dedicated curling brush design instead.

Questions people ask

Which is better for length, Maybelline or L'Oréal Telescopic?

L'Oréal's Telescopic Original is the lengthening option, with a brand claim of up to 70% longer-looking lashes. Lash Sensational is the volume option.

Is L'Oréal Telescopic safe for contact lens wearers?

L'Oréal's UK page says it is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Is Maybelline Lash Sensational waterproof?

Not necessarily. Maybelline sells washable and waterproof versions under the Lash Sensational name, so check the pack. The listing here describes a flake-free, volumizing formula and doesn't call it waterproof.

How long does Telescopic last?

L'Oréal says up to 36 hours of wear, based on its own 108-subject consumer test.

Sources

Prices are pulled live from Amazon.

Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Make-up or see the whole Beauty department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.