Earth Rated vs Amazon Basics Dog Poo Bags: Which Should You Buy?
Recycled-plastic bags from a B Corp brand against a bigger own-brand case of 300.
Earth Rated Earth Rated Dog Poo Bags, Guaranteed Leak Proof and
Amazon Basics Amazon Basics Dog Poop/Waste Bags without Dispenser, Lavender, 300
Side by side
| Earth Rated Dog Poo Bags, Guaranteed Leak | Amazon Basics Dog Poop/Waste Bags without Dispenser | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | See on Amazon → | See on Amazon → |
| Rating | ★★★★★ 4.8 | ★★★★★ 4.7 |
| Review count | 145,773 | 5,986 |
| Brand | Earth Rated | Amazon Basics |
| Highlights |
|
|
Our verdict
Buy Earth Rated if the recycled content matters to you or you want the brand's stated 100% leak-proof guarantee. Buy Amazon Basics if you just want a large supply of lavender-scented bags in a similar size. Both are about 33 cm by 22 cm per bag on tear-off rolls, so the decision is recycled content and brand claims against bag count. Pack sizes on the listings differ, so compare bags per roll and rolls per pack before choosing.
Which one is for you?
- Suits owners who want recycled plastic and a brand that backs its leak-proof claim, and don't mind a smaller case. Read our full look at the Earth Rated Dog Poo Bags, Guaranteed Leak →
- Suits owners who want a plain, large supply of scented bags for daily walks without paying attention to brand extras. Read our full look at the Amazon Basics Dog Poop/Waste Bags without Dispenser →
Material and leak-proofing
Earth Rated says its bags are made with 65% certified post-consumer recycled plastic, and its homepage also states it's B Corp certified. The product copy calls the bags extra long, extra strong and 100% leak-proof. Those are brand claims, but they're specific ones you can hold the company to.
For Amazon Basics the listing says the bags are leak-proof and help minimise odour, but gives no recycled-content figure. If you care about recycled plastic, only one of the two states a number.
Size, count and rolls
The Earth Rated pack in this comparison is 270 lavender-scented bags on 18 refill rolls, each bag 22 cm by 33 cm. Earth Rated also sells other pack sizes, and a US retailer listing for a 360-count version shows 20 bags per roll, so always check the exact pack you're ordering.
The Amazon Basics case is 300 bags: 20 rolls of 15, each bag about 33 cm by 22.9 cm. The listing mentions a dispenser-friendly perforated roll but the product is sold without a dispenser, so you'll need a holder or a pocket. That's slightly more bags than the Earth Rated pack for a nearly identical bag size.
Scent and day-to-day use
Both packs are lavender-scented. Scent only masks smell, so tie the bag well either way. Small rolls of 15 to 20 bags are easy to keep in coat pockets and spare ones go in the car or by the door.
Who should skip both
If you want bags certified compostable, neither listing makes that claim: Earth Rated's is about recycled plastic content, not compostability. Check your council's rules on bagged dog waste too. If you're also shopping for your dog, see our Dentastix vs Whimzees comparison, or browse dog supplies.
Questions people ask
Are Earth Rated poop bags really leak-proof?
Earth Rated describes them as 100% leak-proof, and says they're extra long and extra strong. That's the brand's claim, not an independent test.
Are Earth Rated bags biodegradable?
Earth Rated says its bags are made with 65% certified post-consumer recycled plastic. It describes recycled content, not compostability, so don't flush or home-compost them.
Do Amazon Basics dog waste bags come with a dispenser?
No. This listing is the version without a dispenser, 300 bags on 20 rolls of 15.
Which is the bigger bag?
They're almost identical: about 22 by 33 cm for Earth Rated and 22.9 by 33 cm for Amazon Basics, per the listings.
Which is better for the environment?
Earth Rated is the only one of the two that states a recycled-plastic figure (65%) and B Corp status. The other listing gives no environmental claim.
Sources
- Earth Rated, Earth Rated homepage
- PetSmart, Earth Rated Lavender-Scented Leakproof Dog Poop Bags, 360 Count
Prices are pulled live from Amazon.
Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Dogs or see the whole Pet Supplies department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.