Pedigree DentaStix vs Whimzees Dental Chews: Which Should You Buy?
A mainstream daily stick against a vegetarian chew, both aimed at medium dogs.
Pedigree Pedigree DentaStix - Daily Dental Chews For Medium
WHIMZEES WHIMZEES Stix M, Month Box, 30 Pieces –
Side by side
| Pedigree DentaStix - Daily Dental Chews | WHIMZEES Stix M, Month Box, 30 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | See on Amazon → | See on Amazon → |
| Rating | ★★★★★ 4.8 | ★★★★★ 4.5 |
| Review count | 12,301 | 8,368 |
| Brand | Pedigree | WHIMZEES |
| Highlights |
|
|
Our verdict
Choose Pedigree DentaStix if you want the familiar daily stick with a stated tartar claim and a wide 10 to 25 kg medium bracket. Choose Whimzees if you want a short, vegetable-based ingredient list with no animal protein, for example for a dog that reacts to meat. Both brands say one a day, neither replaces brushing, and Whimzees sizes its medium chew for 12 to 18 kg dogs, so check your dog's weight first.
Which one is for you?
- Suits dogs from 10 to 25 kg that tolerate meat-based treats, and owners who want a widely stocked daily stick. Read our full look at the Pedigree DentaStix - Daily Dental Chews →
- Suits dogs from about 12 to 18 kg on a vegetarian chew, or owners who prefer a short ingredient list and a harder chew. Read our full look at the WHIMZEES Stix M, Month Box, 30 →
What each brand claims
Pedigree's DentaStix page describes triple-action care: cleaner teeth, fresher breath and less plaque and tartar. It says the treats are clinically proven to reduce tartar, and the UK medium pack listing puts it at up to 80% when fed daily. The page names no study, so it's a brand claim.
Wellness Pet Food, which owns Whimzees, says daily chewing reduces tartar and plaque in independent kennel studies, and that its Brushzees line carries the VOHC seal. The Stix medium listing makes comparative claims such as plaque prevention up to 80% better than other leading treats. Those are brand statements too, and the VOHC mention refers to a different Whimzees product.
Ingredients and who they suit
Pedigree's page says DentaStix contain no sugar or fillers. The listing also says no artificial colours or flavours.
Whimzees describes its range as vegetable-based and vegetarian with no animal proteins. The ingredient list on the brand page starts with potato starch, glycerin and powdered cellulose, followed by lecithin, yeast, sweet lupin meal and alfalfa extract. That makes it the clearer option when you want to avoid meat.
Sizing and age
Sizing is the practical trap. The DentaStix pack here is for medium dogs of 10 to 25 kg. The Whimzees Stix M box is for medium breeds of 12 to 18 kg, and the listing says not for dogs under 9 months. Wellness says adult chews are for dogs over 9 months, puppies need Whimzees Puppy chews, and dogs that gulp should go up a size or ask a vet.
Pedigree says DentaStix aren't suitable for puppies and should be fed one a day, with size-specific guidance on pack. Always supervise chewing with either brand, and count the chew toward daily calories.
Who should skip both
Neither replaces brushing or professional dental care, and Wellness says so for Whimzees. If your dog has gum disease or loose teeth, ask your vet before giving hard chews. For other dog buys, see Earth Rated vs Amazon Basics poo bags or the dog supplies category.
Questions people ask
Are Whimzees better than Dentastix?
Whimzees is the better pick for a meat-free, short-ingredient chew. DentaStix is the better pick if you want the established daily stick and a wider weight bracket.
Are Whimzees vegetarian?
Wellness Pet Food describes its dog chews as vegetable-based and vegetarian with no animal proteins.
How many DentaStix should a dog have a day?
Pedigree suggests one a day, with size-specific feeding guidelines on the pack. They're not suitable for puppies.
What age can dogs have Whimzees?
Adult chews are for dogs over 9 months, per Wellness Pet Food. Younger dogs from 3 months should have the Puppy chews.
Do dental chews replace brushing?
No. Wellness states that chews don't replace brushing or professional cleanings, and Pedigree's claims are about reducing build-up, not removing the need for dental care.
Sources
- Pedigree, Pedigree DentaStix
- Wellness Pet Food, Whimzees
Prices are pulled live from Amazon.
Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Dogs or see the whole Pet Supplies department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.