Herd Mentality – Udderly Hilarious Family Board Game for 4–20 Players | Easy to Learn, Loved by Millions, with Bonus Online E
Product details checked 5 September 2026 · price checked live
Check price on Amazon →Overview
We track Big Potato Herd Mentality – Udderly Hilarious Family Board alongside 48 other games products, comparing it on rating, how many people have rated it and what it currently costs. According to the listing: Flip a question and guess what everyone else is thinking. Land in the majority and win cows — be the odd one out, and the dreaded pink cow of doom is yours. There are no right or wrong answers, just popular ones. Finding out how your family and friends think is half the fun, and the results are almost always brilliantly surprising. Those are the seller's own claims rather than our testing, so treat them as a starting point. On Amazon it holds 4.7 out of 5 from 5,997 ratings. What that score is worth next to its rivals is set out below.
- Brand
- Big Potato
- Amazon rating
- 4.7 / 5 from 5,997 ratings
- vs Games
- level with the category median of 4.7
- Rank in category
- 13 of 49 rated games we track
- Price position
- Towards the top of the range (category spans £2.99 to £55.99)
- How proven
- Well established, above-average review volume
Price range as of · details
How it compares in Games
Across the 49 rated games products we track, the typical score is 4.7 out of 5. This one sits at 4.7, which is around the middle of the category. Ratings alone will not separate it from its rivals here, so price and the specifics below matter more than the star count.
It carries 5,997 ratings against a category median of 2,518. That is enough of a base to take the score seriously without treating it as settled.
On price it sits in the upper third of a category running from £2.99 to £55.99, where the midpoint is about £10.42. Paying above the category norm needs a reason beyond the rating, because the score alone does not justify the gap here.
Category prices as of · details
Worked out from the 49 games products in our catalogue, not from the brand's own claims. How we rank →
Key features, as the manufacturer lists them
Taken from the product listing via Amazon's product API. These are the seller's claims, not our test results.
- THINK LIKE THE HERD, OR FACE THE PINK COW: Flip a question and guess what everyone else is thinking. Land in the majority and win cows — be the odd one out, and the dreaded pink cow of doom is yours.
- REVEALS HOW YOUR FRIENDS THINK: There are no right or wrong answers, just popular ones. Finding out how your family and friends think is half the fun, and the results are almost always brilliantly surprising.
- BRILLIANT FOR HUGE GROUPS: Built for 4 to 20 players, making it one of the few games that genuinely works for big family gatherings, Christmas, Boxing Day, and parties where most games fall flat.
- OPEN THE BOX & PLAY: No complicated setup, no lengthy rules explanation — easy to learn in moments and endlessly replayable, the kind of game that gets pulled out again and again.
- A GUARANTEED CROWD-PLEASER: Loved by families across the UK, suitable for kids, teens, and adults aged 10+ — a cracking gift that always gets played.
