ChoiceTally is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Currency & Subscription Cards · Head to head

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate vs Nintendo Switch Online: Which Should You Buy?

A large, rotating game library on one side, an online-play and retro service on the other.

XBOX Game Pass Ultimate – 1 Month Membership - Download Code Xbox

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate – 1 Month Membership

★ 4.4 / 5 4,651 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →
Nintendo Switch Online Membership - 3 Months | Switch Download Code Nintendo

Nintendo Switch Online Membership - 3 Months

★ 4.5 / 5 1,996 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →

Side by side

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate – 1Nintendo Switch Online Membership - 3
PriceSee on Amazon →See on Amazon →
Rating★★★★☆ 4.4★★★★★ 4.5
Review count4,6511,996
BrandXboxNintendo
Highlights
  • Play Forza Horizon 6, Fable, and more new games on day one* on any screen. Choose from a library of 400+ games…
  • Download and play games on XBOX console, PC and supported handhelds. Skip the download and stream games (inclu…
  • Join your friends to play, chat and explore together with online console multiplayer.
  • You’ll be able to play co-operative and competitive games online by signing in with your Nintendo Account.
  • With this paid service, you can enjoy online multiplayer gaming as well as a dedicated smart device app that c…
  • Members will have ongoing access to a library of classic games with added online play, such as Super Mario Bro…

Our verdict

They aren't rivals so much as different things on different consoles. Game Pass Ultimate suits you if you own an Xbox or gaming PC and want a big library with new games on day one. Nintendo Switch Online suits you if you own a Switch or Switch 2 and want online multiplayer, cloud saves and a growing set of classic games. Game Pass is a games library, while Switch Online is closer to an online-play subscription with retro extras.

Which one is for you?

What each membership includes

Xbox's page lists Game Pass Ultimate with new games on day one, a library its plan card puts at 400+ games (the FAQ says 500+), EA Play, Fortnite Crew and Ubisoft+ Classics. It adds 15 hours of cloud gaming a month, online console multiplayer and Rewards points. This listing is the 1 month download code.

Nintendo says membership covers online play, the Nintendo Switch App, Nintendo Music, Save Data Cloud and libraries of NES, Super NES and Game Boy games. The 3 month code here is the standard tier, and the Expansion Pack, with Nintendo 64, Game Boy Advance and SEGA Mega Drive libraries and some DLC, is a separate higher tier.

Where each one works

Game Pass runs on Xbox consoles, PC and supported handhelds, and streams to phones, tablets, TVs and VR headsets. Nintendo Switch Online is for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2 accounts, and some features on Switch 2, such as GameChat, are tied to that console.

Neither works as a substitute for the other. If you're deciding which console to buy, that's a bigger question than the subscription.

Saves, trials and term length

Nintendo says Save Data Cloud backs up most Switch and Switch 2 games, but not every title, and that you can renew within 180 days to restore access after a lapse. Individual memberships come in 1, 3 or 12 month terms. A 7 day free trial is available for the standard tier, but not for the Expansion Pack.

Game Pass downloads on console need the subscription active to keep playing the library titles, and Xbox lists cheaper tiers (Essential, Premium and PC) if you don't need everything in Ultimate.

Who should skip both

If you only play a couple of games you own and don't play online, you might not need either. Also note the PlayStation has its own subscription. For more subscriptions and cards see game subscription cards.

Questions people ask

Is Game Pass better than Nintendo Switch Online?

For library size and new releases, yes: Game Pass Ultimate offers 400+ games and day-one releases. For Nintendo games and cloud saves on a Switch, Switch Online is the one you need.

Can I use Game Pass on a Nintendo Switch?

Xbox's page lists Game Pass for Xbox consoles, PC, supported handhelds and streaming to phones, tablets, TVs and VR. A Switch isn't listed.

Do I need Nintendo Switch Online to play online?

Yes. Nintendo says membership is what gives you online play in supported games, along with Save Data Cloud and the classic game libraries.

What is the difference between Switch Online and the Expansion Pack?

Expansion Pack includes everything in standard membership plus Nintendo 64, Game Boy Advance, Virtual Boy and SEGA Mega Drive libraries and DLC for selected games.

Does Game Pass Ultimate include multiplayer?

Yes. Xbox lists online console multiplayer in Ultimate, along with EA Play and Fortnite Crew.

Sources

Prices are pulled live from Amazon.

Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Currency & Subscription Cards or see the whole Video Games department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.