ChoiceTally is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Home Textiles · Head to head

Slumberdown vs Silentnight Pillows: Which Should You Buy?

Both are British-made hypoallergenic pillows, but one is a medium-firm four-pack and the other a softer pair.

Slumberdown Pillows 4 Pack Hotel Quality – Firm, Plump Hypoallergenic Pillows for Back & Side Sleepers, Sleep Better. Feel Be Slumberdown

Slumberdown Pillows 4 Pack Hotel Quality – Firm

★ 4.4 / 5 7,957 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →
Silentnight Deep Sleep Pillows 2 Pack – Medium Support Comfortable Hollowfibre Bed for Front, Back and Side Sleepers Machine Silentnight

Silentnight Deep Sleep Pillows 2 Pack – Medium

★ 4.3 / 5 29,374 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →

Side by side

Slumberdown Pillows 4 Pack Hotel QualitySilentnight Deep Sleep Pillows 2 Pack
PriceSee on Amazon →See on Amazon →
Rating★★★★☆ 4.4★★★★☆ 4.3
Review count7,95729,374
BrandSlumberdownSilentnight
Highlights
  • Bounce-Back Rebound Fill – Firm & Plump, Night After Night - Filled with springy, resilient fibres that bounce…
  • Medium-Firm Support for Back & Side Sleepers - A supportive, medium-firm feel that keeps your head, neck and s…
  • Hotel-Quality Comfort, Hypoallergenic Cover - Wrapped in a soft-touch, breathable microfibre cover for a luxur…
  • DEEPER SLEEP: Sink into deeper sleep with generously filled pillows that provide endless comfort and support, …
  • SOFT/MEDIUM SUPPORT: Use one pillow for soft comfort or two pillows for firmer support, with this pack contain…
  • HYPOALLERGENIC DESIGN: Kind to skin and does not include any contents likely to cause allergies, suitable for …

Our verdict

Pick Slumberdown if you want medium-firm pillows for back and side sleeping and need four of them. Pick Silentnight Deep Sleep if you prefer a softer pillow, or want to stack two for firmer support, and only need a pair. Both say they're made in the UK with a two-year guarantee and are machine washable, so firmness and pack size are the deciding facts.

Which one is for you?

Firmness and who it's for

The Slumberdown 4 pack is described as medium-firm, a rebound fill aimed at back and side sleepers who want structure without stiffness. It's a standard 48 x 74cm size.

The Silentnight Deep Sleep pair is described as soft to medium support. A retailer page (MFI) lists it as medium firm, and the listing's own advice is to use one for soft comfort or two for firmer support. The listing also names front sleepers, who generally want a lower, softer pillow.

Pack size and size

The Slumberdown listing is a four-pack, which makes it more practical for a double bed with a spare pair or for a whole house. Silentnight is a two-pack. Retailers give dimensions for the Silentnight pair of 70cm wide, 48cm long and 8cm high at MFI, though other retailers list different depths, so check the one you buy.

Fill, washing and guarantee

Silentnight's pair is hollowfibre, per MFI, and the listing says hypoallergenic and machine washable at 40 degrees. MFI also says tumble drying is fine and gives a two-year guarantee and UK manufacture.

Slumberdown's listing says a soft-touch microfibre cover that's hypoallergenic and dust-mite resistant, machine washable and tumble-dryer friendly. It claims a two-year guarantee and UK manufacture, and Slumberdown's own site carries a 'Made in Britain Certified' badge and lists a 4 pack range.

A B&Q listing for a different Slumberdown firm side-sleeper 4-pack is also described as made in Yorkshire, so the brand's UK-made claim is consistent, though it's a different product.

Choosing by sleeping position

Back sleepers generally want a medium-firm pillow to keep the neck level, and side sleepers need more height to fill the gap between shoulder and head, which is why Slumberdown's firmer, plumper build targets both. Front sleepers usually do best with a soft, low pillow, and Silentnight's one-or-two pillow advice lets you vary the height. Whichever you choose, replace pillows when they stop bouncing back, and wash them on the care label's settings.

Who should skip both

If you suffer neck pain, a single contoured or memory foam pillow may do more than a plain fibre one. For bedding to pair these with, see our fitted sheet comparison or the home textiles category.

Questions people ask

Which is better, Slumberdown or Silentnight pillows?

Slumberdown for a firmer medium-firm pillow and four of them; Silentnight Deep Sleep for a softer feel in a pair.

Are Silentnight Deep Sleep pillows machine washable?

Yes. MFI lists them as machine washable, and the listing says at 40 degrees.

Are Slumberdown pillows made in the UK?

The listing says made in the UK with a two-year guarantee, and Slumberdown's site shows a Made in Britain Certified badge.

Are these pillows good for side sleepers?

Slumberdown's listing targets back and side sleepers with medium-firm support. Silentnight's two-pillow stacking can add height for side sleeping.

Are they hypoallergenic?

Both listings say so. It's a manufacturer claim rather than a named certificate.

Sources

Prices are pulled live from Amazon.

Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Home Textiles or see the whole Home & Kitchen department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.