Seagate Portable vs WD Elements Hard Drive: Which Should You Buy?
Two plain USB 3.0 portable hard drives, and these listings are different capacities, so check that first.
Seagate Seagate Portable Drive 1TB, External Hard Drive, Dark
Western Digital Western Digital WD 2TB Elements AE Portable External Hard
Side by side
| Seagate Portable Drive 1TB, External Hard | Western Digital WD 2TB Elements AE Portable | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | See on Amazon → | See on Amazon → |
| Rating | ★★★★★ 4.5 | ★★★★☆ 4.3 |
| Review count | 265,609 | 1,147 |
| Brand | Seagate | Western Digital |
| Highlights |
|
|
Our verdict
They are close to identical in what they do: bus-powered, plug-and-play USB 3.0 hard drives for backups and file storage. The listings here differ in capacity (1TB Seagate against 2TB WD), so compare like for like before deciding. The Seagate listing adds a 2 year warranty with data recovery service and Mac reformatting guidance, while the WD listing is formatted for Windows and includes backup software. Mac users should expect to reformat either drive.
Which one is for you?
- Suits Windows or Mac users who want a simple 1TB drive with the manufacturer's recovery service named in the listing. Read our full look at the Seagate Portable Drive 1TB, External Hard →
- Suits Windows users who want 2TB and a scheduled-backup tool, and don't mind reformatting if they ever move to a Mac. Read our full look at the Western Digital WD 2TB Elements AE Portable →
Same idea, different capacities here
Seagate's own page says its drive is bus-powered over USB, so there is no wall adapter, and says its Portable drive comes in 1TB, 2TB, 4TB and 5TB and uses USB 3.0. WD's page describes the Elements Portable as offering fast transfers over USB 3.2 Gen 1 or USB 3.0, which is the same 5Gbps class under a different name.
The Seagate Portable Drive listing is the 1TB model; the WD Elements 2TB listing is double that. If you only need 1TB, look for the same size on both brands rather than comparing across tiers. The WD listing says the range goes up to 6TB.
Mac, Windows and formatting
The WD listing says it is formatted for Windows. The Seagate listing describes it as working with Windows or Mac and lists Mac compatibility as reformat compatible. Seagate's page says it works with PC, Mac and Chromebook, is plug-and-play with no software or drivers, and that you may need to reformat to use it across both Windows and Mac.
In short, treat both as Windows-first. A Mac user should plan to reformat either drive before first use (which erases it), or choose a file system both platforms read.
Extras and warranty
The Seagate listing mentions a 46cm USB 3.0 cable, a two-year limited warranty and two-year rescue data recovery services. Seagate's product page itself doesn't state the warranty length, so confirm it on the seller's page.
The WD listing highlights backup software you download and schedule hourly, daily or monthly, and an enclosure made from more than 50% post-consumer recycled plastic. We couldn't confirm WD's warranty length from the pages opened, so check it before buying.
Remember these are spinning hard drives. They give far more space for the money than an SSD but are slower and less tolerant of knocks. If you carry a drive in a bag daily, consider the Samsung T7 vs SanDisk Extreme SSD comparison.
Who should skip both
If you need quick transfers of large video files or a drive that survives drops, an SSD is a better fit. And a single external drive isn't a full backup strategy: keep a second copy. Other drives are listed under data storage.
Questions people ask
Seagate or WD external hard drive: which is better?
For basic backups they are close. Pick on capacity, warranty terms and extras: the Seagate listing names a data recovery service, the WD listing names backup software.
Does the Seagate Portable Drive work with a Mac?
Yes, with a caveat. Seagate says it works with PC, Mac and Chromebook, but you may need to reformat it to use it across both Windows and Mac.
Does the WD Elements work on Mac?
The listing says it is formatted for Windows, so reformatting is expected before Mac use. Check WD's page for current macOS notes.
Do these drives need a power adapter?
Seagate's page says its drive is bus-powered over USB. The WD listing describes the Elements as plug-and-play, so check WD's page for power details.
Is USB 3.2 Gen 1 faster than USB 3.0?
No. USB 3.2 Gen 1 is a renaming of USB 3.0, so both are the same 5Gbps class.
Sources
- Seagate, Seagate Portable External Hard Drive
- Western Digital, WD Elements Portable product page
Prices are pulled live from Amazon.
Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Data Storage or see the whole Computers & Accessories department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.