ChoiceTally is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Scanners & Accessories · Head to head

Kodak Slide N Scan vs Magnasonic Film Scanner: Which Should You Buy?

Two similar stand-alone scanners with one big format difference: Super 8.

KODAK SLIDE N SCAN Film and Slide Scanner with Large 5” LCD Screen, Convert Color & B&W 35mm, 126, 110 Negatives & Slides to KODAK

KODAK SLIDE N SCAN Film and Slide Scanner

★ 4.4 / 5 12,296 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →
Magnasonic All-In-One 24MP Film Scanner with Large 5" Display & HDMI, Converts 35mm/126/110/Super 8 Film & 135/126/110 Slides Magnasonic

Magnasonic All-In-One 24MP Film Scanner with Large 5"

★ 4.3 / 5 2,923 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →

Side by side

KODAK SLIDE N SCAN Film andMagnasonic All-In-One 24MP Film Scanner with
PriceSee on Amazon →See on Amazon →
Rating★★★★☆ 4.4★★★★☆ 4.3
Review count12,2962,923
BrandKODAKMagnasonic
Highlights
  • SAVE OLD PHOTO MEMORIES: 1422MP Digital Film Scanner Lets You View, Edit and Convert Your Old Color and BandW …
  • 5” LCD DISPLAY WITH GALLERY MODE: Features Large, Crystal-Clear Screen with Wide Viewing Angle for Instantly P…
  • CONVENIENT EASY-LOAD FILM INSERTS: Quick-Feeding Tray Technology Allows for Continuous Loading Action, Making …
  • PRESERVE OLD MEMORIES - Quickly and easily converts 35mm/110/126/Super 8 film negatives & 135/126/110 slides i…
  • MULTIPLE WAYS TO VIEW - Using the stunning 5'' LCD screen, view your film, slides & scanned images directly on…
  • BUILT-IN MEMORY & SD CARD SLOT - With a convenient 128MB internal memory and an SD card slot for up to 128GB o…

Our verdict

Choose the Magnasonic if you have Super 8 film, or want to use a larger SD card, because the Kodak doesn't list Super 8 and caps cards at 32GB. Choose the Kodak if you only have 35mm, 110 and 126 film, want the HDMI cable and 50mm slide holder included, and like its gallery mode. Both output interpolated resolution, not true megapixels, so don't pay for the headline number.

Which one is for you?

Formats supported

The Kodak Slide N Scan handles 135, 110 and 126 colour and black-and-white negatives and 50mm slides, per Kodak's product page. The Magnasonic adds Super 8 film (35mm, 126, 110 and Super 8 film plus 135, 126 and 110 slides). Magnasonic says it doesn't support 127, 120, 220 or 116 formats.

For Super 8 reels, that makes Magnasonic the only one of the two to consider.

Resolution: read the small print

Kodak quotes a 14MP CMOS sensor with 22MP interpolated output. Magnasonic's product page lists a 16MP sensor with output up to 24MP interpolated. Marketing numbers on listings are the interpolated figures, so the real gap is 14MP against 16MP: small.

Storage, power and connections

Kodak needs an SD or SDHC card (up to 32GB, not included) to operate. Magnasonic's own page lists no internal memory and SDHC cards up to 128GB; one retailer listing mentions 128MB internal memory, which contradicts that page, so assume you need a card.

Both have a 5 inch LCD and HDMI out. Kodak includes the HDMI and USB cables and runs from a computer, a 5V/1A adapter or a power bank. Magnasonic's HDMI cable is not included, and it ships with a mini USB-to-USB cable.

Magnasonic quotes 3 to 5 seconds per scan and on-device brightness, colour and flip adjustments. Kodak offers a one-touch scan and a gallery mode that can show images as a photo frame.

Who should skip both

If you have hundreds of negatives and want the best detail, a dedicated film scanner with true high resolution or a lab service will beat both. These suit casual family archiving.

Getting good results

Whichever you choose, clean the film and slides before scanning. Dust shows up at 14 or 16 megapixels, and neither scanner can repair scratches or fading (Magnasonic says so explicitly).

Scan to an SD card first, then copy files across to a computer for backup. Kodak's page says the card is required to operate, so buy a decent SD card at the start. Check each scanner's card size limit: 32GB for Kodak, 128GB for Magnasonic.

If you have mixed collections, count the rolls by format before you buy. Super 8 reels are the one case where the choice is made for you.

Questions people ask

Does the Kodak Slide N Scan do Super 8?

Kodak's page lists 135, 110 and 126 negatives and 50mm slides, with no Super 8 support. The Magnasonic does list Super 8.

Do I need an SD card for these scanners?

Kodak says an SD card is required (up to 32GB, not included). Magnasonic's page lists no internal memory and SDHC up to 128GB.

Is the Magnasonic really 24MP?

Magnasonic lists a 16MP sensor with output interpolated up to 24MP. Kodak is similarly 14MP interpolated to 22MP.

Which is better, Kodak or Magnasonic?

Magnasonic if you need Super 8 or bigger cards; Kodak if you want cables and holders included and only have standard formats.

Can I connect them to a TV?

Yes, both have HDMI output. Kodak includes the cable; Magnasonic doesn't.

Sources

Prices are pulled live from Amazon.

Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Scanners & Accessories or see the whole Computers & Accessories department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.