ChoiceTally is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Camera & Photo · Head to head

Instax Mini Film vs Polaroid i-Type Film: Which Should You Buy?

They are not interchangeable: the camera you own decides the film, so this is about which system to buy into.

INSTAX mini instant film White Border, 20 shot Pack, suitable for all mini cameras and printers INSTAX

INSTAX mini instant film White Border, 20 shot

★ 4.7 / 5 219,776 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →
Polaroid 6000 Color Film for i-Type, 8 Films Polaroid

Polaroid 6000 Color Film for i-Type, 8 Films

★ 4.4 / 5 34,532 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →

Side by side

INSTAX mini instant film White BorderPolaroid 6000 Color Film for i-Type
PriceSee on Amazon →See on Amazon →
Rating★★★★★ 4.7★★★★☆ 4.4
Review count219,77634,532
BrandINSTAXPolaroid
Highlights
  • Produce credit card sized instax mini film, print size 54 (W) x 86 (H) image size 46 (W) x 62 (H) mm
  • Suitable for all instax mini series cameras, mini SHARE and Link photo printers and LiPlay and mini -EVO Hybri…
  • ISO 800 Film
  • UPDATED CLASSIC: The classic film is back with a new formula exclusively for I-Type cameras. It uses Polaroid'…
  • LIGHT IT UP: Polaroid Instant Film loves light. The more light in your shot, the better your photo will turn o…
  • DEVELOP: All photos appear blank at first. Photos develop within 15 minutes. Shield photos from the light and …

Our verdict

You cannot put one in the other's camera, so check your camera first. If it is an Instax Mini camera or Mini printer, buy Instax Mini film. If it is a Polaroid Now, OneStep 2, I-2 or Lab, buy i-Type. If you have no camera yet, Instax Mini gives you small credit-card prints and more shots per pack, while Polaroid gives you the larger square print and the classic look, with a longer wait for the image to develop.

Which one is for you?

Different film, different cameras

The Instax Mini film listing says it suits all Instax Mini series cameras, Mini SHARE and Link printers, and the LiPlay and Mini EVO hybrid devices. The Polaroid i-Type film is made for Polaroid's i-Type cameras. Castle Cameras names the I-2, Now, Now+, Lab, OneStep 2 and OneStep+, and states it is not compatible with vintage Polaroid cameras such as the 600, because the pack has no battery.

That last point catches people out: an old Polaroid 600 camera needs 600 film, not i-Type. And neither film fits the other brand's camera.

Print size and pack contents

Instax Mini prints are credit-card sized. The listing gives a film size of 54 x 86mm with a 46 x 62mm image, in a 20-shot pack here. Polaroid i-Type gives 8 photos per pack. Castle Cameras lists a 79 x 79mm image area inside a 107 x 88mm frame, so the picture is square and noticeably larger.

Instax is the one for wallets, fridge doors and scrapbooks. Polaroid is the one you prop on a shelf.

Developing and storage

Castle Cameras and the Getty shop both list 10 to 15 minutes for i-Type to develop. The Polaroid listing tells you to shield each photo from light, place it face down, shoot in bright light or use the flash, and store the film chilled in the fridge without freezing it.

The Instax listing here describes ISO 800 film using Fujifilm real film technology. We could not open Fujifilm's own page for a development time, so check the pack for it.

Who should skip both

If you want to share photos digitally as well, a hybrid camera or printer is the better route: the Instax listing mentions Mini Link and LiPlay for that. See our camera and photo guides for other options.

Questions people ask

Can I use Instax Mini film in a Polaroid camera?

No. Instax Mini is a different format and fits only Instax Mini cameras and compatible Mini printers. Polaroid cameras take Polaroid film.

Can I use Polaroid i-Type film in an old 600 camera?

No. Castle Cameras says i-Type is not compatible with vintage cameras such as the 600 because the film pack has no battery. Use 600 film in a 600 camera.

How long does Polaroid i-Type film take to develop?

The retailers we opened list 10 to 15 minutes. Keep the photo shielded from light and face down while it develops.

How many photos are in a Polaroid i-Type pack?

Eight. The Instax Mini pack in this comparison holds 20 shots.

Which is better for a beginner, Instax Mini or Polaroid?

Choose by the camera you want. Instax Mini cameras and 20-shot film packs suit casual snapping, and Polaroid suits people who want the bigger square print and do not mind the wait.

Sources

Prices are pulled live from Amazon.

Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Camera & Photo or see the whole Electronics department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.