Baby Einstein Magic Touch Piano vs Kids Piano Keyboard: Which Should You Buy?
A simple wooden piano for babies against a louder, busier keyboard for older toddlers.
Baby Einstein Baby Einstein Hape Magic Touch Piano Wooden Musical Toy
Amy & Benton Amy & Benton AmyBenton Baby Kids Piano Keyboard, 24 Keys
Side by side
| Baby Einstein Hape Magic Touch Piano Wooden | Amy & Benton AmyBenton Baby Kids Piano Keyboard | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | See on Amazon → | See on Amazon → |
| Rating | ★★★★★ 4.7 | ★★★★☆ 4.2 |
| Review count | 17,751 | 1,459 |
| Brand | Baby Einstein | Amy & Benton |
| Highlights |
|
|
Our verdict
Pick the Baby Einstein Magic Touch Piano if the child is under about two: Kids2 lists it for 6 to 36 months, it has six songs and a volume switch, and there are no tiny controls to fiddle with. Pick the AmyBenton keyboard if you want something to grow into: 24 keys, a microphone, demo songs and an external audio input suit a child who wants to sing along. They are different toys at different stages, not rivals on the same shelf.
Which one is for you?
- Parents of babies and young toddlers who want a quiet-ish, wooden first instrument with a volume control. Read our full look at the Baby Einstein Hape Magic Touch Piano Wooden →
- Families with a two or three year old who wants a microphone, demo songs and lots of buttons to press. Read our full look at the Amy & Benton AmyBenton Baby Kids Piano Keyboard →
Age range and what the child actually does
Kids2, the maker of Baby Einstein, lists the Magic Touch Piano for 6 to 36 months. There are no keys to press: you touch the colour-coded notes and it plays. It comes with three sheets of music and six songs, and the listing describes modes for making your own tune or following a familiar one.
The AmyBenton keyboard is a different kind of toy. The listing title markets it as a gift for 3 to 7 year olds, and the bullet points describe 24 keys, 8 percussion sounds, 4 instruments, 22 demo songs and a karaoke microphone. A baby will mostly bash it; an older toddler can actually use the features.
Build, size and care
Kids2 gives the Baby Einstein piano's materials as roughly 55% wood, 40% plastic and 5% electronics, needs no assembly, and says to wipe it with a damp cloth and mild soap, never immerse it. Its listed footprint is about 12 inches wide.
The AmyBenton is moulded ABS plastic according to its listing, with three legs that fold together, so check the size details before buying and expect to attach the legs. The listing also warns that if the microphone doesn't work on arrival you should contact the seller.
Batteries, sound and noise
Kids2 says the Magic Touch Piano takes 3 AA batteries, not included, and has low and high volume settings. Some retailers list batteries as included, so check the specific listing you buy.
The AmyBenton uses 4 AA batteries (not included, per its listing), and it can play music from a phone or MP3 player through its external input. More features means more noise options, and no mention of a volume limit in the listing we read, so expect it to be the louder of the two in a small room.
Practical buying tips
Before you buy, think about where the toy will live. The wooden piano is compact and sits happily on a shelf or the floor, so it can come out for a few minutes at a time. The keyboard has folding legs and a stand, so it needs a bit of floor space and a minute of setup each time.
Think about the sound too. A touch piano with set songs is predictable, which many parents prefer around a baby. A keyboard with percussion, instruments and a microphone is more fun for a two or three year old, but also more likely to be played at full tilt. Keep spare AA batteries handy for either, and take them out if the toy will be stored for weeks.
Who should skip both
If you want a real instrument for lessons, neither does the job: look at a weighted-key keyboard instead. For a baby under 12 months who just needs something to chew and tap, a simple rattle or a musical toy from the musical toy instruments range will do. See also our piano dance mat comparison for floor-based options.
Questions people ask
Which toddler piano is better for a one year old?
The Baby Einstein Magic Touch Piano. Kids2 lists it for 6 to 36 months, whereas the AmyBenton listing markets itself at 3 to 7 year olds.
Does the Baby Einstein Magic Touch Piano need batteries?
Yes, 3 AA batteries. Kids2 says they are not included, though a few retailers list them as included.
Does the AmyBenton keyboard have a microphone?
Yes. The listing describes a karaoke microphone and an external input for a phone or MP3 player.
Can I wash the Baby Einstein piano?
Wipe it with a damp cloth and mild soap, then air dry. Kids2 says do not immerse it in water.
Sources
- Kids2 (Baby Einstein), Magic Touch Piano musical toy
- Amazon UK listing, AmyBenton 24 Key Piano Keyboard Toy
Prices are pulled live from Amazon.
Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Musical Toy Instruments or see the whole Toys & Games department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.