ChoiceTally is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Home Care & Cleaning · Head to head

Andrex vs Cushelle Toilet Roll: Which Should You Buy?

Two soft 24-roll packs: Andrex leans on skin-friendliness claims, Cushelle gives you the sheet count and roll length.

Andrex Family Soft Toilet Roll - 24 Toilet Rolls, Bulk Buy, Fragrance Free, FSC Certified Andrex

Andrex Family Soft Toilet Roll - 24 Toilet

★ 4.6 / 5 57,036 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →
Cushelle Simply Soft Toilet Roll 24 Standard Rolls Cushelle

Cushelle Simply Soft Toilet Roll 24 Standard Rolls

★ 4.4 / 5 2,613 reviews
Checking latest price…
Check price on Amazon →

Side by side

Andrex Family Soft Toilet Roll Cushelle Simply Soft Toilet Roll 24
PriceSee on Amazon →See on Amazon →
Rating★★★★★ 4.6★★★★☆ 4.4
Review count57,0362,613
BrandAndrexCushelle
Highlights
  • Fragrance Free: Toilet paper that's gentle on your family’s skin, fragrance free and dermatologically tested, …
  • Toilet Paper Made in the UK: Packaging made with 30% recycled plastic
  • Pair our Toilet Roll with Plastic Free Andrex Fresh and Sensitive Wipes: Squeeky Cheeky Clean Pair To Feel Eve…
  • If you're searching for a soft toilet paper that is suitable for even the gentlest of skin, then try NEW Cushe…
  • Cushelle packaging can be recycled in store*. We've partnered with ERIC, The Children's Bowel and Bladder Char…
  • Average 170 sheets per roll. 2ply tissue

Our verdict

Both are soft, standard-roll toilet tissues from big UK brands, and on the facts available there is no dramatic winner. Pick Andrex Family Soft if you want a fragrance-free tissue with dermatological and British Skin Foundation backing claims and 'made in the UK' on the listing. Pick Cushelle Simply Soft if you like to know exactly what you're getting: an average of 170 two-ply sheets and 19.89m per roll. Softness is personal, so try a smaller pack of each if you're unsure.

Which one is for you?

What each listing actually states

The Andrex Family Soft 24-roll pack is described as fragrance free, dermatologically tested and made from 100% soft natural fibres, with packaging containing 30% recycled plastic and FSC certification. It says it's made in the UK and approved by the British Skin Foundation. A retailer page we read describes the Andrex range as supported by research recognised by the British Skin Foundation, which is a more limited claim than approval, so read the pack.

The Cushelle Simply Soft listing is more numerical: an average of 170 sheets per roll, 2-ply, an average roll length of 19.89m and 24 rolls per pack. Cushelle's own site lists Simply Soft among its toilet roll lines, with ply, sheet count, recyclable packaging and FSC details in the product footnote.

Sheets and value per roll

Only Cushelle states a sheet count in the listing text: 170 on average. The Andrex listing gives no sheet count or roll length in the text provided, so we can't compare which roll lasts longer. Check the pack to compare actual sheets before assuming either is better value.

Softness and skin

Both brands market softness. Andrex adds fragrance-free and dermatologically tested claims, plus the British Skin Foundation mention. Cushelle's listing says it is suitable for even the gentlest skin. Neither claim is independently tested here, so if someone in the house has sensitive skin, fragrance-free labelling is the clearer signal.

Packaging and causes

Cushelle's listing says packaging can be recycled in store and mentions a partnership with the children's bowel and bladder charity ERIC. Andrex packaging features a QR code linking to bowel cancer symptom information through its Bowel Cancer UK partnership. Both are worth knowing if packaging or the cause influences your choice.

Who should skip both

If you want a plastic-free pack, tubeless rolls or a different ply, check other lines in the home care and cleaning category. Toilet roll is a repeat buy, so the best choice is the one that suits your household and fits your storage.

Questions people ask

Which is softer, Andrex or Cushelle?

Both claim to be soft and neither claim is independently compared here. Try each and decide.

How many sheets are on a Cushelle Simply Soft roll?

An average of 170 sheets on a 2-ply roll, roughly 19.89m long, per the listing.

Is Andrex Family Soft fragrance free?

Yes, the listing describes it as fragrance free and dermatologically tested.

Are they FSC certified?

The Andrex listing says FSC certified. Cushelle's own site notes FSC details in the Simply Soft footnote.

Is Cushelle recyclable?

The listing says the packaging can be recycled in store.

Sources

Prices are pulled live from Amazon.

Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Home Care & Cleaning or see the whole Grocery department. New to the category? Start with our buying guide.