ChoiceTally is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Pet Supplies guide

How to Choose Dog Treats: Training, Dental and Everyday Rewards

Treats are a big part of life with a dog, whether you’re training, rewarding good behaviour or looking after their teeth. But not all treats are equal, and it’s easy to overdo them. Here’s how to choose treats that are useful and healthy, and use them wisely.

The short version

Match the treat to the job: small soft treats for training, dental chews for teeth, and healthier options for everyday. Keep treats to around 10 percent of daily calories, and count them as part of your dog's food.

Match the treat to the job

Different treats suit different purposes:

  • Training treats should be small, soft and tasty, so your dog eats them fast and stays keen.
  • Dental chews support teeth between brushing as part of a routine.
  • Everyday treats are for rewards and enrichment, where a healthier, lower-calorie option is a good idea.

Having the right type on hand makes each job easier.

Dental chews for dogs Dental chews support teeth as part of a daily routine. Check price on Amazon →

Watch the calories

This is the one owners forget. Treats count towards your dog’s daily food, and it’s easy to quietly overfeed with a few here and there. A common guide is to keep treats to around 10 percent of daily calories, and to reduce meals slightly on days with lots of training rewards.

Read the label

Just like their main food, the ingredients matter. Look for treats without unnecessary fillers, and be mindful of anything very high in fat or sugar. If your dog has allergies or a health condition, check the ingredients carefully and ask your vet.

Enrichment beyond food

Not every reward has to be edible. Chews, puzzle feeders and toys keep dogs occupied and happy without the calories, which is handy for dogs watching their weight. Mixing food and non-food rewards keeps things interesting for them.

Ready to choose?

Browse current top-rated dog supplies, ranked by real owner reviews, then check today’s price on Amazon.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This guide is general information, not veterinary advice.

Frequently asked questions

How many treats can I give my dog?

Treats should make up no more than around 10 percent of your dog's daily calories. Factor them into their overall food so you don't accidentally overfeed.

What treats are best for training?

Small, soft, tasty treats work best for training, since your dog can eat them quickly and stay focused. You can break larger treats into tiny pieces to make them last.

Do dental chews actually help?

Dental chews can help reduce plaque and tartar between brushing as part of a routine, but they aren't a replacement for proper dental care. Ask your vet if you have concerns.